Cake Vs. Pie

[Dragonfly]

All I'm gonna say is all of the above please.

It good to have such a high metabolism...

[U-Turn]

GRex
and Peach Cobbler is the BEST

only thing better than peach cobbler is peach cobbler with Blue Bell Vanilla Ice Cream

AMEN !

[Firewa11]

All I'm gonna say is all of the above please.

It good to have such a high metabolism...

You and your high metabolism sucks!

[Meat of Snail]

All I'm gonna say is all of the above please.

It good to have such a high metabolism...

You and your high metabolism sucks!

all the better to suck down tastey food

[WillK675]

All I'm gonna say is all of the above please.

It good to have such a high metabolism...

You and your high metabolism sucks!

all the better to suck down tastey food

And that tastey food would be pie, not cake.

[GRex]

And that tastey food would be pie, not cake.

COBBLER

[WillK675]

And that tastey food would be pie, not cake.

COBBLER

That to.

I'm hungry all the sudden. Hmmm.,me has an idea.... Find small dinner for Pie/Cobbler on the drive back from Houston this afternoon.

[GRex]

Now I need to go to Spring Creek BBQ. Good BBQ and Cobbler!

[WillK675]

Good idea. Maybe I'll do that for dinner as I should be getting back in town sometime during the 1900 hour.

[Meat of Snail]

FLAN

[sckego]

[Firewa11]

Flan is neither cake nor pie, so it should't be mentioned. Neither is this a creme brulee thread. We're not talking about pudding, cookies, candies, or other dessert or non dessert items. This is a Cake vs. Pie thread. Let's stay focused! Especially considering flan is disguisting.

Cobbler can be mentioned because it's basically what happens when grandma got lazy with rolling the pie crust!

[WillK675]

Cobbler can be mentioned because it's basically what happens when grandma got lazy with rolling the pie crust!

Also, it falls into this description...

Pie is typically a desert that has a filing that is completely contained by a crust

[sauter0966]

al a mode

[WillK675]

I took Marsha and the T-Rex down to Hico and had pie. . . seemed much better than hanging around for the tornadoes..

see not only is Pie > cake... but in this math class we have also learned that pie > tornados.

[Blizzard_1708]

yes, thank you Will

[WillK675]

Welcome!

[GRex]

I took Marsha and the T-Rex down to Hico and had pie. . . seemed much better than hanging around for the tornadoes..

see not only is Pie > cake... but in this math class we have also learned that pie > tornados.

Ok, so go the other way - what is worse than tornados, and why.

Something like this:
Tornados > Earthquakes. The ground moves over a very large area, and there is no warning. Tornados are generally isolated, and there are clear weather warnings - that's why I was eating pie while the tornados were messing with Midlothian

[WillK675]

Here is the bracket... and the winner is Pie!!!

now here is the kicker...
where do Cheese Cake and Boston Cream Pie fit into the mix?

From the braket above cheese cake is a Pie, and win's it. Now I'm not so sure on this one, but here is the controversy and their conclusion.... link

And yet, some people simply cannot accept that cheesecake is a pie.


The Selection Committee maintains that a key ingredient in any Cheesecake is a crusty base. Moreover, it does not rise. Cakes, generally speaking, rise. But the crust factor is inarguable. Cheesecake is a Pie, and Pie wins.

Clicky for the full tournament, it's rules, and guidlines, and all that jazz.

[Meat of Snail]

interesting that boston cream pie is on the pie side, I would not have put it there, I still think the boston cream pie belongs on the cake side...

oh, and by the way, good find

[WillK675]

I'm with you. And i'm not totally 100% that cheese cake should be included in the bracket at all. But on the crust factor, it would be a pie.

[fireblade]

Cake will stand alone, with out support from a tin

Pie will not stand alone. I'm talking whole pies not just a slice.

[sckego]

Pound cake as a nine seed and lemon meringue as a 13 are both travesties. What crappy-ass, no-taste-bud-having committee set that bracket? At least the best option came away with the championship. I hear that Creme Brulee dominated the NIT.

[Meat of Snail]

As for cheese cake, before it sets, the filling is just like most pie fillings (liquid) and then after cooking and seting if the fridge it will set and hold its own. Cheese Cake is a pie with a cleaver name meant to strike conversations...

[fireblade]

there for CAKE IS A LIE!!!